Logo Homeschool World ® Official Web Site of Practical Homeschooling Magazine Practical Homeschooling Magazine
Practical Homeschooling® :

Reading Comprehension Part 4: Logical Reasoning

By Michael Maloney
Printed in Practical Homeschooling #72, 2006.

Pin It

Michael Maloney


So far in this series on reading comprehension, we have looked at literal comprehension, inferences, and deductive thinking. In this final segment, we turn our attention to logical reasoning. In more advanced courses, students are asked to determine whether the position taken by the writer is logically reasonable. They have to decide whether or not the statements made in the author's presentation contain a logical fallacy. In order to determine the logical solidarity of a position or argument, the student needs to be able to test the author's case against the known rules for any valid argument. That assumes that the student knows the various rules of argument, can understand these rules and can systematically apply them to the stated position of any author.

Rules of Argument

There are six specific rules for determining whether or not an argument is valid. Sigfried Engelmann first made these rules explicit in his early work on reading comprehension. Many times students are expected to find the flaw in a presentation without being specifically aware of the six tests which the presentation must be able to pass. Students are more likely to be successful in determining the validity of an argument if they can use specifically stated rules as tests of the author's position. To assist them, the six rules of argument are specified below with examples in which the rule is broken.

Rule #1: Just because two things happen at the same time this does not mean that one thing causes the other.

Example: Every time I sit down to read my book, the phone rings. My mother has not called me all week. I am going to read my book so that she will call today.

The student has to determine whether the conclusion the author wants you to reach violates this argument by drawing a conclusion based on proximity of two events in time. The student has to reject the conclusion because the rule tells them that there is no causal connection between the events.

Rule #2: Just because you know about a part this does not mean that you know about the whole thing.

Example: The headlights on my car are not working. We can't go anywhere now because the car probably won't start.

In order to apply this rule the student needs to be able to discriminate between wholes and parts. They then can determine that just because one part does not function, it does not mean that other parts, or the entire entity will not.

Rule #3: Just because you know about the whole thing this does not mean that you know about every part.

Example: Dogs have a good sense of smell and great vision, so they must have great hearing as well.

Again the student has to differentiate between the parts and the whole and know the limits to which an argument applies. The argument cannot be extended to aspects that are not specifically stated. The student has to discern that we have no information about this particular part of the organism and therefore cannot apply the same conclusion as we did for those parts for which we do have information.

Rule #4: Just because the words are the same, this does not mean that they have the same meaning.

Example: The farmer was so poor that even his ducks had bills.

The student has to know that there is more than one meaning for the term "bill."

There are many words which have more than one meaning. Using such words could lead to the student choosing a meaning that was not intended and then draw a faulty conclusion.

Rule #5: Just because the information presents some choices, this does not mean that there are no other choices.

Example: When the price of oil goes up, we have to raise the price we charge for gas immediately.

The student has to be aware that other choices have not been presented. The price increase might not have to occur until the gas station buys a new shipment of the more expensive gasoline. In this case, the author is limiting the choices to those which favor his position. The student has to determine what other possibilities exist that explain the conclusion so as to weigh the argument in light of all of the possible choices.

Rule #6: Just because an event happened in the past this does not mean that it will or will not happen again.

Example: The restaurant that was here before went bankrupt. I guess this new one will probably go bankrupt too.

The student has to know that there are factors other than history that will affect the outcome for this event. This is similar to the first rule about the effect of time on events. There is no causal or predictive connection between time and the event which is being presented.

Using the Rules

Once students learn the rules about valid argument they can be much more insightful in formulating the conclusions that they draw. Students can apply these lessons to everyday experience. When they see an advertisement that presents a beautiful woman or a handsome man as part of the copy with some product, they can spot the flaw that says that just because two things occur at the same time the one does not cause the other. They can then conclude that just because you buy this product, you will not necessarily attract beautiful people or be perceived as more attractive.

Students can apply the rules for argument in a variety of situations. At any time when they are editing information, writing a position paper or responding to someone else's, the rules will assist them to spot logical flaws, overgeneralizations and omissions. The rules can be used in teaching oral debating or other forms of interactive public speaking.


Was this article helpful to you?
Subscribe to Practical Homeschooling today, and you'll get this quality of information and encouragement five times per year, delivered to your door. To start, click on the link below that describes you:

USA Individual
USA Librarian (purchasing for a library)
Outside USA Individual
Outside USA Library

Time4Learning University of Nebraska High School

Articles by Michael Maloney

The Maloney Method

Frequency and Fluency - New Ways to Measure Student Performance

How to Teach Reading & Measure Your Child's Reading Skills

Arithmetic Fluency: Some Ideas for Achieving It

Spelling Fluency: Pre-Drills for Teaching Spelling

Teaching Reading Comprehension Skills

Fluent Grammar

More Results in Less Time: The One-Minute Drill That Works

Teaching Fluent Handwriting Skills

Teaching Fluent Handwriting Skills, Part 2

Teaching Fluent Keyboarding Skills

Building Fluent Vocabulary

Building Fluent Reading Comprehension Skills, Part One

Reading Comprehension, Part 2: Inference

Reading Comprehension Part 3: Deductive Reasoning

Reading Comprehension Part 4: Logical Reasoning

Geography and History at the Crossroads

Practical Geography Facts and Numbers

Teaching Geography

Teaching Geography Using the DI Approach

Learning Geographic Concepts and Terms

Teaching Abbreviations Using Flashcards

The Geography of Victory and of Defeat

Popular Articles

Interview with John Taylor Gatto

The Equal Sign - Symbol, Name, Meaning

A Reason for Reading

Why the Internet will Never Replace Books

Don't Give Up on Your Late Bloomers

The Charlotte Mason Method

University Model Schools

Montessori Language Arts at Home, Part 1

Laptop Homeschool

Combining Work and Homeschool

Getting Started in Homeschooling: The First Ten Steps

Start a Nature Notebook

The Gift of a Mentor

Character Matters for Kids

What We Can Learn from the Homeschooled 2002 National Geography Bee Winners

Teach Your Children to Work

Whole-Language Boondoggle

Getting Organized Part 3

Shakespeare Camp

Advanced Math: Trig, PreCalc, and more!

I Was an Accelerated Child

How to Win the Geography Bee

Bears in the House

Saxon Math: Facts vs. Rumors

Top Jobs for the College Graduate

Top Tips for Teaching Toddlers

What Does My Preschooler Need to Know?

A Homeschooler Wins the Heisman

Phonics the Montessori Way

The History of Public Education

Columbus and the Flat Earth...

Teaching Blends

Myth of the Teenager

Patriarchy, Meet Matriarchy

Art Appreciation the Charlotte Mason Way

Can Homeschoolers Participate In Public School Programs?

Classical Education

The Charlote Mason Approach to Poetry

Getting Organized Part 1 - Tips & Tricks

AP Courses At Home

Discover Your Child's Learning Style

The Benefits of Debate

Critical Thinking and Logic

Narration Beats Tests

Give Yourself a "CLEP Scholarship"

Joyce Swann's Homeschool Tips

How to "Bee" a Spelling Success

Montessori Math

Who Needs the Prom?

The Benefits of Cursive Writing