Logo Homeschool World ® Official Web Site of Practical Homeschooling Magazine Practical Homeschooling Magazine
Practical Homeschooling® :

Education vs. Regurgitation

By Jessica Hulcy
Printed in Practical Homeschooling #19, 1997.

Pin It

Jessica Hulcy


As a successful product of public school, I am often asked, "Why did you and your husband choose to homeschool your four boys?" True, I was a member of the National Honor Society, in honors science and honors English, and even voted Most Likely to Succeed - giving the appearance of being one smart kid. Then I took the SAT test. When the results arrived, my counselor called me into her office, showed me my low scores, and advised me not to attempt college.

Why this huge disparity between my poor standardized test scores and my stellar twelve-year academic performance? Two things were at play.

First, many people do not perform well on standardized tests. When I took my GRE to enter graduate school, I again scored poorly. A brilliant friend, who had taken the test with me, called to compare scores. When I told him my score, he said, "No, Jessica, add the verbal and the non-verbal scores together." I replied, "I already have." Standardized tests are not my cup of tea, and yet, in graduate school the bulk of my grades were A's, sprinkled with B's.

The second explanation is that I was well-trained in regurgitation. With a photographic memory, I could fill in blanks, receive A's, and promptly forget my regurgitated answers. Public school was product-, grade-, and results-oriented. There is still some of that thrust today. The emphasis is on passing the TAAS test, with weeks to months spent teaching the test! I was a shining example of one who could pass the test, graduate with honors, and not even be educated! If homeschooling parents and public school teachers want to break out of the product-oriented mold, unleashing children's creativity and thinking, what can they do differently?

Discovery Learning Fosters Creativity and Thinking

Discovery learning usually involves a hands-on approach. This also naturally lends itself to problem solving. Children come up with solutions to problems without following prescribed step-by-step instructions. The child himself must think through the solution and determine his own steps.

When I taught in public schools, I prided myself on making my science classes hands-on, by showing my students a picture of a complete circuit, giving them the components, and allowing them to construct a complete circuit, per the diagram. As my friend, David Quine, would say, "Why not give each child a C-battery, a flashlight bulb, some paper clips, and see who can make his bulb light first?" Real discovery learning does not tell an answer. It poses a problem that causes light bulbs to go on in children's minds.

I recently received an email from a women who loved the hands-on, discovery approach for her children but was married to a clean-freak. While the mother wanted the children to set up a huge model ear that they could crawl through under the dining room table, the father preferred filling in workbooks. To him, messiness was non-learning, yet learning and retention clearly increase through multi-sensory, discovery learning. Fortunately, the mothers of Thomas Edison, the Wright brothers, and Teddy Roosevelt allowed their young boys' genius to develop amid a mess. These mothers' tolerance of messes netted the 20th century the light bulb, the airplane, and a US President. I am convinced that the Yankee ingenuity of yesterday has been stifled today by adults' compulsion for children to fill in workbook blanks.

There are many new unit study curricula out on the homeschool market, yet a closer look reveals that all unit studies are not created equal. Successful unit studies not only have a central theme and offer many related activities and projects based on that theme, they also encourage discovery learning. Discovery learning is not merely the absence of instructions; it is the absence of instruction plus the presence of carefully constructed open-ended questions that lead children to the next thought, then the next thought, and finally to the big concept that connects their single activity to the larger issue being studied.

Why construct a model ear to crawl through under the dining room table if the emphasis is not on the Creator's intricate design of the ear and the ear's purpose - attentiveness to God and His creation? Otherwise, the projects become little more than activities for activities' sake. Those activities that lead to the consideration and discovery of existing truths are worthy of our time.

Dialogue Stretches Students' Thinking Skills

Product-oriented education is obsessed with the answer, rather than the thought behind the answer. Dialogue, on the other hand, draws answers out of students, while demanding that students think in the process. Anyone who has seen the movie Shadowlands, recounting the life of C. S. Lewis, has seen the art of dialogue at its best. At Oxford and Cambridge, young men came to class ready to dialogue with their mentor about what they had read. C. S. Lewis posed question after question to the students, each time insisting that the views they held be proved and supported. While a workbook asks for a single word to be regurgitated, dialogue asks for an original thought to be articulated and supported. Because homeschool class sizes are small, homeschooling parents have the unique opportunity to use dialogue to stretch their child's reasoning and thinking ability by asking open-ended questions, such as, "What would happen if... ?", "Which solution do you think is best?", "Can you support your belief?"

Beware of unit activities that end with phrases such as, "tell your children..." or "read to your children..." as the consistent bottom line. Of course, as parents we are continually speaking and reading to our children, but if our curriculum ends there, we are merely teaching on the surface. Only when we engage in dialogue with our children do we dig into the heart of learning, encouraging our children to think and understand.

I encourage homeschooling parents who desire to raise thinkers to employ the methods of discovery and dialogue. Real thinkers cannot help but be educated. As my friend, Erin Blain, says, "Be obsessed with education, not graduation." Allow graduation to take its proper place as the icing on the cake of education.


Was this article helpful to you?
Subscribe to Practical Homeschooling today, and you'll get this quality of information and encouragement five times per year, delivered to your door. To start, click on the link below that describes you:

USA Individual
USA Librarian (purchasing for a library)
Outside USA Individual
Outside USA Library

Time4Learning University of Nebraska High School

Articles by Jessica Hulcy

How to Avoid Mindless Unit Studies

Make Drama Part of Your Unit Studies

Do Your Units End with a Bang or a Whimper

Costumes Add Color to Your Unit Studies

Safety First

Columnists Face Off - Unit Studies

Politics the Homeschool Way

What Are Unit Studies All About?

Multi-Culturalism Replaces History

High School Unit Studies Prepare Students for Adulthood Interaction

Picking Curriculum Carefully

How to Give Your Child a Theistic Worldview

To College or Not to College

Brotherhood Begins in the Heart

Education vs. Regurgitation

The Importance of Mentoring

One Word of Advice: Balance!

Teaching the Basics with Unit Studies

Study Units or Unit Studies?

Thanks for the Memories

99¢ Feather Duster or $90 Warbonnet?

Co-oping: The Very Best of Both Worlds

The Key to Exceptional Co-Op Days

Meeting True Heroes Face to Face

From Living Room to Front Lawn: Performances

Co-oping Younger and Older Students Together

Co-op Field Trips: True Three-Dimensional Learning

The Ultimate Field Trip... Europe

The Making of a Master Teacher

Laughter and Movement: Fertilizer for the Brain

Popular Articles

Can Homeschoolers Participate In Public School Programs?

What We Can Learn from the Homeschooled 2002 National Geography Bee Winners

Montessori Language Arts at Home, Part 1

Give Yourself a "CLEP Scholarship"

The Charlote Mason Approach to Poetry

Columbus and the Flat Earth...

Art Appreciation the Charlotte Mason Way

Phonics the Montessori Way

Bears in the House

The Charlotte Mason Method

Who Needs the Prom?

The History of Public Education

Why the Internet will Never Replace Books

University Model Schools

Don't Give Up on Your Late Bloomers

AP Courses At Home

Getting Started in Homeschooling: The First Ten Steps

Character Matters for Kids

Critical Thinking and Logic

The Equal Sign - Symbol, Name, Meaning

The Benefits of Debate

Classical Education

Shakespeare Camp

The Gift of a Mentor

A Reason for Reading

Getting Organized Part 3

I Was an Accelerated Child

Teaching Blends

Myth of the Teenager

Montessori Math

Laptop Homeschool

Discover Your Child's Learning Style

How to "Bee" a Spelling Success

Narration Beats Tests

Top Jobs for the College Graduate

Getting Organized Part 1 - Tips & Tricks

Advanced Math: Trig, PreCalc, and more!

Teach Your Children to Work

How to Win the Geography Bee

Top Tips for Teaching Toddlers

Patriarchy, Meet Matriarchy

The Benefits of Cursive Writing

Saxon Math: Facts vs. Rumors

Combining Work and Homeschool

Joyce Swann's Homeschool Tips

Start a Nature Notebook

What Does My Preschooler Need to Know?

Interview with John Taylor Gatto

Whole-Language Boondoggle

A Homeschooler Wins the Heisman