Thought-provoking answers to this frequently-asked question
ur modern culture, even within the church, can accept just about
anything as long as it’s only an “option.” Bungee jumping for Jesus?
Good for you! Home schooling? Hey, whatever the Lord leads you to do is
But the follow-up question is always, “Do you believe it’s for
everyone?” Nervous eyes search your face for some clue as to what’s
coming. If you begin to suggest that home schooling is best, you’ll be
cut off. Home schooling is fine—for you. Just be quick to admit it’s
only your personal choice.
The question behind “Should everybody home school?” is actually “Do I
have to?” At a deeper level the question is, “Will God be angry if I
don’t?” A “yes” at any level is a moral judgment. Eyes roll. Onlookers
glance at one another with that, “Oh, give me a break!” look. Small
wonder that even the most confident Christian home-schoolers are quick
to say, “Of course, home schooling isn’t for everyone.”
But think about what this diplomatic answer is saying. It may be taken
as code for, “Don’t worry, folks; I’m not a fanatic. I’m a reasonable
person who has simply exercised my personal right to choose home
schooling as one of many equally legitimate alternative educational
options. Don’t think that just because I have chosen to teach my
children at home that I am suggesting in any way that home education
would be good for your children!” Is this really the message we intend
Some parents are looking for any way out of having to deal with their
children. Don’t make it too easy on them by being so quick to say, “No,
home schooling is not for everyone.” Home schooling may be for them.
I know that some circumstances render home schooling temporarily
impractical. Failing health, financial crisis, and emotional instability
are real obstacles. Christian schools may be needed temporarily. Even
public schools may be the only option in some extreme circumstances. But
bad circumstances eventually change, and the best available education
will again be found at home. The question is, will we be honest enough
to admit it?
When we choose what we know is not the best available for our children,
whether for personal convenience or out of fear of what others might
think, we have a real reason for feeling guilty. By this measure, a lot
of parents today are guilty of negligence. Temporary exceptions to the
rule don’t change the rule. Should everyone give their children the best
available education? Yes. Is the home normally the best available? Yes.
Then, to knowingly choose to do otherwise is sin.
The evidence is all on the side of home schooling. The public schools
can’t be fixed. If you’re still not so sure about that, then read The
Right Choice by Chris Klicka. But if you know it’s true, why not say so
I’m not suggesting that we should be intentionally annoying. But most of
us would do well to add godly courage to our consideration for other’s
feelings. The issues at stake require boldness.
When people ask, “Do you believe everyone should home school?” be calm.
Answer, “If you mean, ‘Do I believe that every home should be a place
where children receive instruction from their parents?’ then the answer
is yes. Can you think of any reason for it to be otherwise?” Put the
ball back into their court. Don’t let them write you off as unrealistic,
but don’t let them off the hook either. Think before you speak.
When people follow up with, “Well, surely you don’t expect everyone to
take his children out of school?!” don’t retreat. Answer with yet
“What do people do with their children when school is not in session? I
believe their education should be part of the family routine. Home
schooling is a lifestyle that makes room for education.”
In my experience, when parents attempt to do even a little bit of what
they are capable of after school, on the weekends and during summer
breaks, they soon come to realize that conventional schooling is a
disruption of the best available education.
Some say, “Well, I would home school, but my church has a Christian
school and I want to support its ministry.” Ask those parents if they
would put their children in an orphanage if their church started one.
“Of course not!”
Orphanages, reform schools, Christian day schools, youth groups, and
even Sunday schools fit into the same category. They are all
institutions designed to make up for what is lacking in weak or broken
families. By all means, support them for the sake of those who need
them. Use them if you need them. But don’t use them if you have
Granted, in the short term, we won’t keep as many friends with this
approach. But by speaking the truth in love, thousands more families
will eventually come around to seeing things more clearly. All it takes
is another crisis in the local schools for things to sink in.
God’s word, we are told, falls as rain and snow. (See Isaiah 55:10-11.)
On a warm heart, it falls as rain, and the results can be felt
immediately. But on a cold heart, God’s word falls as snow. It piles up,
but it doesn’t go away. When a thaw finally comes, all that snow melts.
A change of heart can open a person up to truth that was once
unacceptable. Most of us know this by our own experience.
So don’t back down. Nothing in God’s kingdom was ever accomplished until
someone was willing to be called a “fanatic.” The apostles, prophets and
reformers were not thin-skinned folk. To see revival they had to be
willing to endure a riot. The same truths can result in either—or both!
So be honest. Say, “Home schooling is for everyone!”
Was this article helpful to you?
Subscribe to Practical Homeschooling today, and you'll get this quality of information and encouragement five times per year, delivered to your door. To start, click on the link below that describes you:
USA Librarian (purchasing for a library)
Outside USA Individual
Outside USA Library